Twenty-three months ago, I bought a mug. On its side it reads: ‘I finished The Power Broker’. Last weekend, I qualified for the first time to use it. That mug is not the only Power Broker merch in my possession. The NYC mayor’s office put out a film a couple of months ago in which Zohran Mamdani uses The Power Broker as a prop. Earlier this month, people gathered in Brooklyn for a 66-hour readathon of the book. The word ‘iconic’ is bandied around far too liberally, but Robert Caro’s 1974 classic 1,300 page biography about the New York public official, Robert Moses, is certainly that.
The community and subculture that has grown up around Robert Caro in general and The Power Broker in particular means that it’s possible to consume the book differently from a ‘standard’ biography. So, although you shouldn’t expect a review of The Power Broker on this website for several months (I want to read more on the subject first, which tells you all you need to know about the interest that the book will generate) here are some thoughts about the experience of reading it.
You don’t need to know anything about urban development.
This is a book about how one man acquired and used power. With that power he built roads, bridges, parks and housing. You’ll learn about how those things are developed, but you don’t need any prior knowledge. It helps if you’ve ever been on a road, or in a house. That’s as much expertise as you need.
You don’t need to know anything about politics in New York.
Understand the difference between New York City and New York State. Caro will explain the rest.
You won’t learn everything there is to know about urban development, or politics in New York.
It’s well documented that about 600 pages were cut from the original manuscript before The Power Broker’s eventual publication. So you may find yourself with additional questions or areas to explore. I’ve ended up with a further reading list: another book on Robert Moses, one about and one by Jane Jacobs, one about the long gestation of a New York subway line, and the script of the David Hare play, Straight Line Crazy.
The book is pretty fair to its subject.
Caro is quite damning of the man that Robert Moses became, and the short-sightedness and cruelty he displayed, but he lists his accomplishments fairly and clearly has admiration for Moses’ earlier vision, energy and idealism.
It’s a rollicking read: history but with a journalist’s eye for a story.
Caro knows how to tell a story. He uses journalistic and literary devices to keep you hooked. It’s easy not to be bored – but the relentlessness of Moses’ activities may mean you need to cleanse your spirit from time to time.
You can read along with a podcast.
Elliott Kalan and Roman Mars from the excellent 99% Invisible ran a series of monthly read-along episodes back in 2024, with guests such as Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Pete Buttigieg, Conan O’Brien and Robert Caro himself. Kalan and Mars are excellent guides and there is no doubt that listening along has made me pick up different perspectives and get more out of the reading experience. The t-shirt they produced is the other Power Broker merch I own, and as well as looking cool it has a certain slimming effect. Such is the quality of the discussion that the Power Broker Book Club series is now hosted directly on Robert Caro’s website.
